Energy Storage Economics

From EPRI Storage Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search


Under construction icon-blue.png
This page is under development. In the meantime, feel free to browse. Please check back later for additional changes.


Cost Components and Trends

Clarity on costs is a critical component of energy storage economics. Economic analysis of energy storage systems need to clearly articulate what major components are included in the scope of cost. The schematic below shows the major components of an energy storage system.


Source: EPRI. Understanding the components of energy storage systems is a critical first step to understanding energy storage economics.


Other generation resource costs are often communicated on a $/kW basis, but energy storage has both power and energy components and the normalized cost will vary with duration. This is highlighted in two examples below. Clarity on costs is a critical component of energy storage economics. Economic analysis of energy storage systems need to clearly articulate what major components are included in the scope of cost. The schematic below shows the major components of an energy storage system.


Source: EPRI.



Source: EPRI.

Grid Services and Uses

Energy storage has many capabilities:

  • Capacity Resource: Firm power
  • Flexibility Resource: Fast response and ramping
  • Backup Resource: Energy reserve
  • Power Quality Resource: 4-quadrant watts and VARs


The table below list the grid services energy storage can support.
Es101app1.png
Transmission-connected storage may provide:

  • Generation capacity (resource adequacy)
  • Black start
  • Virtual transmission capacity
  • Energy time-shifting
  • Ancillary services


Distribution-connected storage may provide:

  • Virtual distribution capacity
  • Enhance power quality
  • Resiliency / backup power / microgrid
  • Upstream transmission impacts – either costs or benefits


Customer-connected storage may provide:

  • Customer bill savings: Retail time-of-use tariff energy shifting, Demand charge management
  • Backup power
  • Upstream T&D impacts – either costs or benefits


Modeling Energy Storage

Challenges to modeling energy storage include:

  • Storage is not yet a common grid asset
  • Rules and regulations are still evolving
  • Benefit stacking is appealing, but is it possible?
    • More services = more value
    • More services = more requirements
    • Can these requirements be satisfied?
  • Storage value analyses are site-specific
  • Complex co-optimization between storage technologies, objectives, and constraints


Understanding Service Compatibility

  • Energy Storage Services Hierarchy
    • Energy storage services only flow from bottom up, customer storage may provide distribution and transmission-level services, but transmission storage can NOT provide distribution or customer services
  • Reliability vs. Economic
    • Reliability takes priority (e.g. T&D deferral higher priority than market services)
    • Long-term planning constraints take priority to economic optimization and constraints roll-up; Multi-year >> Annual >> Monthly >> Day-ahead >> Real-time
  • Local vs. System Level
    • Local objectives generally supersede system objectives when there is a conflict (e.g. T&D deferral higher priority than resource adequacy) although should be designed so that reliability services never conflict

Resources


EPRI Tools to Support Valuation Modeling
StorageVET
DER-VET
Reports

Resource Access Level
EPRI Solar Plus Storage Cost Assessment and Design Considerations: Executive Summary (2019) Publicly Available
EPRI Energy Storage Technology and Cost Assessment: Executive Summary (2018) Publicly Available
ESIC Energy Storage Cost Tool and Template Publicly Available
Energy Storage Valuation in California: Policy Planning and Market Information Relevant to the StorageVET Model Publicly Available